A Folk-Fueled Journey Through the Deep South
South of Midnight transports players to a beautifully realized vision of the American Deep South, where folklore isn’t just stories, it’s reality. As protagonist Hazel Flood, you’ll face supernatural creatures and encounter age old magic while embarking on a deeply personal quest. But does this Southern Gothic adventure deliver a complete package, or is its charm limited to its visual and narrative elements? After completing the full journey, I’ve found a game with genuine heart and artistic vision, but one that doesn’t quite fulfill its gameplay potential.
Uneven Gameplay in a Captivating World
South of Midnight’s moment to moment gameplay feels like it’s serving primarily as a vehicle for the story rather than a highlight in its own right. Combat starts with promise, there’s a genuine thrill in early encounters where fleeing from larger threats creates genuine tension. As Hazel gains supernatural abilities, there are flashes of satisfaction in how these powers interact with the environment and enemies.
Unfortunately, the gameplay loop grows repetitive by the halfway point. Enemy encounters follow predictable patterns, often funneling you into arena style battles that must be completed before progression. Boss fights, despite their visual spectacle and fantastic musical accompaniment, tend to rely on straightforward patterns that offer little strategic challenge.
The platforming elements and environmental puzzles fare somewhat better, providing a pleasant if unambitious way to explore the game’s gorgeous bayous and destroyed buildings. Collectibles scattered throughout add motivation for thorough exploration, but many players will find themselves wishing for more variety in the gameplay mechanics as hours pass.
A Story of Myth and Emotion
Where South of Midnight truly shines is in its storytelling. Hazel’s quest to save her mother drives a narrative that weaves together personal drama and regional folklore with remarkable authenticity. The game avoids leaning on tired Southern stereotypes, instead offering a nuanced, respectful portrayal of the region’s culture and mythology.
The character writing deserves particular praise, Hazel is well realized and relatable, with Adriyan Rae’s voice performance bringing genuine emotional depth to the role. Supporting characters similarly feel three dimensional, each with their own motivations and histories that intersect meaningfully with the main story.
While the pacing stumbles in places, a sluggish opening chapter and somewhat abrupt conclusion bookend an otherwise well structured tale, the overall narrative arc leaves a lasting impression. South of Midnight tells a story that feels both intimately personal and mythically grand, balancing its supernatural elements with very human emotions.
Visually Stunning Artistry
It’s impossible to discuss South of Midnight without highlighting its exceptional visual presentation. Compulsion Games has crafted one of the most distinctive looking titles of the year, blending a stop motion inspired animation style with richly detailed environments. Characters move with deliberate, frame skipping animations reminiscent of SpiderVerse’s visual language, giving the game a uniquely cinematic quality.
The art direction perfectly captures the game’s Southern Gothic atmosphere, misty bayous, moonlit forests, and crumbling architecture create a world that feels simultaneously real and fantastical. The creature designs are especially noteworthy, drawing from regional folklore to create memorable supernatural entities that feel both authentic and original.
Technical performance is similarly impressive, with the game running smoothly even during visually complex sequences. South of Midnight establishes a new visual benchmark for how the American South should be portrayed in gaming, and other developers would do well to take notes.
A Symphony of Southern Sounds
The audio design in South of Midnight deserves special recognition for its creative approach to the soundtrack and exceptional voice performances. The musical score draws from a rich tapestry of Southern genres like blues, folk, gospel, and more, creating a soundscape that enhances both the setting and emotional beats of the story.
Boss encounters are particularly memorable thanks to the dynamic soundtrack, which builds in intensity as confrontations escalate. Each major spirit has its own musical theme, incorporating vocals and traditional instruments in ways that make these moments stand out as some of the game’s highest points.
Voice acting throughout is strong, with Adriyan Rae’s performance as Hazel being especially noteworthy. The only minor complaint lies in some repetitive dialogue lines that can grow tiresome during extended play sessions. Overall, the audio presentation creates an immersive experience that perfectly complements the game’s visual style and narrative themes.
Conclusion: Beauty Over Substance?
South of Midnight is a game of contrasts, visually stunning but gameplay conservative, narratively engaging but mechanically repetitive. Its greatest strengths lie in its cultural authenticity, artistic vision, and emotional storytelling. These elements combine to create an experience that will likely stay with players long after completion, even as the actual gameplay fades from memory.
For players who value atmosphere, story, and artistic direction above challenging gameplay systems, South of Midnight offers a journey worth taking. The immersive world Compulsion Games has created deserves to be experienced, even if the mechanics binding it together don’t always reach the same heights.
For more details on our review criteria, please refer to our Review Policy.
Stay Connected with Zane Mercer
Loved the review? Don’t miss out on more gaming deep dives, wild “What Ifs,” and brutally honest takes!
YouTube: @ZaneMercerTV
X (Twitter): @ZaneMercerTV
Twitch: Twitch.tv/ZaneMercer
TikTok: @ZaneMercerTV
